4.8
97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
All Citizens
4.8 • 331 Reviews
•

4.8
97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
3y ago
Of all the "pouch" underwear out there, ALL CITIZENS in my experience has made the perfect product! Most pouch underwear are made for those well endowed, but for those of us who are "average" they work just as well :) After trying out a few different brands, from now on I will continue with All Citizens.
3y ago
New discovery I can't wear anything else now. Make sure you purchase enough for the week.
3y ago
As I'm sure has been the experience of many others of you, I used to wear those crappy 3/$10 boxer briefs because I didn't know any better. This past spring, I decided I needed a change, and did a bunch of research to find the best pair for me. Ultimately, I settled on All Citizens, and I couldn't be happier. They have a bunch of different fits and styles available to cater to every individual. I got their Elite II Trunks, and they fit me perfectly, look great, and feel great, especially in the pouch area. All-in-all, easy five stars for the product themselves, and support was super helpful and accommodating with me when I placed my order.
3y ago
I have bought the Elite ll and love them, just bought the Apex lll love them more. These underwear are so comfortable, I like the new Apex lll as they have a protective lining to keep the boys safe. Love the way everything is held in a comfortable position, no sticking to my leg. All of mine are boxer briefs. Will be buying more of the Apex lll. Only thing bad, is limited colors.
3y ago
I have tried several brands in search for the perfect trunk. One that is comfortable, the legs don't ride up, and are affordable. Everything from budget to designer brands (in my drawer currently: Hanes, Mr. Davis, Jockey, Amazon Aware, Shinesty, Mack Weldon and now All Citizens). I'm happy to report that All Citizens ticks off all my checkboxes. They are extremely comfortable, the legs don't ride up at all, and compared to other premium brands that claim to have all these features, they do it better and are more affordable. The pouch didn't work for me personally but they fortunately have a pouch-less version. Try them, you will not regret it. I'm about to order a bundle!
3y ago
Ron B. I bought boxer briefs from several other retailors looking for support and comfort. I then bought one pair of the Re: Luxe boxer briefs as a trial. The comfortable fabric, good fit, convenient top fly, and support the pouch gives, sold me. The pouched boxer briefs give me everything I looked for, and at a lesser price than other brands. I'm a return customer. I highly recommended!
3y ago
I bought a full closet reset of their underwear and I am hooked. I had a trip out to Las Vegas here recently and it kept me cool and dry the entire trip, even in a heat wave! Highly recommend and will be getting more soon!
3y ago
I don't know where to begin, I have been spending my well earned money on some uncomfortable cheap underwear all these years then I find All Citizens. Game over before it even started, as long as I live I will never buy another brand if underwear. I have never worn a pair of underwear that no matter what I did that day there was no ride up, slip down or uncomfortable ball situation at all. It is like having a pillow lined pillow for my boys and I must say they love it!!! A HUGE thank you to the geniuses at All Citizens, my nuts have never been so happy.
3y ago
Love the ball pouch in the boxer briefs. Keeps me from sticking in my legs or sitting on my boys! The waistband is great never rolls over. Keeps me from chafing all day at work when I walk 12 to 15 miles of shift!
3y ago
The quality is unmatched by companies trying to copy hands down best boxer/briefs I've ever purchased
3y ago
I have tested many brands and while these aren't my favorite they are very close. The method used to 'secure your package' is well thought out. The only issue I have is that the whole 'package' gets pressed together making a non-mobile sweaty mess (live in Texas). Everything else though was great - the quality of the material, the bands that keep the legs from riding up, the parachute/kangaroo style exit to the pouch... I not only recommend everyone try these but I also bought some as gifts for those that I know appreciate quality underwear.
3y ago
Thoughtfully designed underwear, socks, shorts, shirts
3y ago
Wonderful underwear. So comfortable. Well worth the money!!!
3y ago
The Elite II boxer briefs are a very comfortable, great material and the newly designed pouch is much better than the original design IMO. The leg grippers really prevent any ride up and like I said earlier the material is very comfortable.
3y ago
I love them, the a material feels amazing and they stay in place. Only downside is they do not have very many designs but hopefully they will introduce more.
3y ago
Comfortable, right-sized, affordable and the horizontal fly is great! I have purchased probably 10 different brands of men's underwear in the last 3 years trying to find the best. From Fruit of the Loom to Jockey, to Saxx, Mack Weldon, Tommy John, and some never heard of brands. AllCitizens is the overall best (although Mack Weldon has the best feel but no horizontal fly). AllCitizens Elite II Trunk is my favorite and I have tried other All Citizens styles. The easy slip in pouch for the boys is great and the horizontal fly is a God send. Love the lightweight material and the grip system around the leg which truly stays in place. I am 5'8" 155 pounds and a 31" waist and the Medium is a perfect fit. The wearability is excellent and I've been washing them in cold water as I think is recommended. That is a bit of a pain because I have so few items also needing a cold water wash. But if you own 7 pairs of All Citizens underwear Like I have done then you wash them all at the end of the week and you are ready for the next week. (I like the variety of colors as well, not real extensive but good enough). I am a fan!
3y ago
So I started out with the paradise pocket briefs absolutely love them and now I have an underwear drawer full of only Paradise pocket briefs recently ordered a T-shirt and pair of socks to try out both are amazing as well and will be buying plenty more of each customer service is par none Kavita has gotten back to me every time I have messaged these guys and has always been super polite and very helpful
3y ago
Thier new elite 2 boxer briefs are the most comfortable beings I’ve worn. Additionally,the only brief I’ve ever found that don’t ride up and crowd/pintch the man bits.
3y ago
I’m old, I grew up a cowboy,I’ve ridden broncs, bulls, anything with hair and four legs. I’ve sailed across the Atlantic in 28 foot boat and ridden the Steppes of Mongolia but I have never worn anything as comfortable as your underwear!
3y ago
I have a large package and suffer from having to carry around a cannon and 2 cannon balls almost as large. By having them in a pouch like this I avoid uncomfortable rubbing and chafing. Having them seperate keeps them more comfortable then any other underwear I’ve tried