All Citizens reviews and discussion

4.8

97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Silky-soft fabric handfeel
  • Secure, supportive pouch design
  • Reliable no-ride leg grippers
  • Convenient horizontal h-fly
  • Occasional heat retention issues
  • Tight thigh bands discomfort
  • Inconsistent pouch ergonomics
  • Limited colors and stock

All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

331 reviews and posts

  • The underwear are awesome. They feel nice and are very comfortable. Highly recommend them

  • Underwear is both comfortable and functional, comes in stylish colors too.

  • I was intrigued by pouch style boxers and thought I'd give these a try. They perform very well at the gym and in casual use as well. Overall, I'd say these are worth every penny. If I had one complaint, it would be that they hold in heat. When it's 90+ degrees out they get extremely hot.

  • Tried boxer elite II boxer briefs and they are great. I’ve made 3 orders so far and plan to buy more.

  • Honestly thought I’d never find a pair of underwear that worked for me. I do structural welding outside in Arizona so needless to say things can get extremely uncomfortable down there. I’ve ordered other pairs of underwear that have claimed to have the best pocket for your junk, but they were either not enough support, or didn’t keep things separated. The paradise pocket is amazing. It holds everything in place, the non-slip leg cuffs keep them from riding up my legs, the mesh keeps things breathing all day long, and the horizontal fly makes it really easy to keep your junk nestled in that pocket while draining the main vein. I bought one pair to try them out, then bought four more pair because I had to have a pair for every day of the work week. Not to mention they’re half the price of all the other ball pocket underwear and outperform all of them. I look forward to purchasing two more pairs of the camo color way once they drop.

  • Solid exercise clothing backed by responsive and helpful customer service team!

  • I have been forever using the big box store boxer briefs and recently came across these boxer briefs... I had no idea these existed and completely changed my underwear drawer! LOVE THESE!! Highly recommend... Just get a pair and you will appreciate the breathability and support!

  • Great underwear, very comfortable. Drawer refresh is a little misleading as the price example is specific to the cheapest style of underwear. Have to be careful to reselect the right size and fit when ordering multiple pairs as the website may default back to athletic fit size small. Overall, they are holding up very well after several months and remain very comfortable.

  • 10/10 you’ll definitely love how these fell so much better. It’s like a great pair of dress socks that don’t pull down haha

  • My husband has an issue with sitting on his balls and is often complaining about this. I figured he cant be the only person with this issue so I began to research underwear and came across All Citizen's ad on Facebook. After reading reviews and checking prices on other products that are similar I went with All Citizen and purchased 1 pair. Needless to say, he loved them after getting used to the change and now I have had to purchase 7 more! He absolutely loves them, and they are super soft and fit really well. I wish they had more prints in stock.

  • Kind of pricy but fit,form, and function are spot on.

  • I have tried a few other types of boxer briefs recently. They all separate the goods from the thighs, but All Citizens goes so much further. I have had penile implant surgery, and other brands were slightly annoying in how much protrusion there was. All Citizens keeps thing nice and tight and SO COMFORTABLE.

  • I've bought 3 pairs so far but I should have received 4. On the last order I purchased 2 and they suddenly went out of stock after the order was replaced. They did nothing to rectify this other than offer to cancel it or send one out after it was back in stock which was going to be a month. Underwear so far seem pretty comfy. Shorter sizes have super tight rings that create indents on my thighs. I wish there was an option for straight leg without this extra constriction. Overall would have been a better review if it wasn't for the customer service

  • An amazing company with even better products. They are constantly looking for improvements to their underwear. I even had issues with the shipping company sending me my pair, and they ended up lost and All Citizens did me a huge favor with my next purchase. Possibly my favorite company, and I’ll happily brag about them.

    Customer
  • These are really great products. The Elite II trunks are great! I'm waiting for more colors - but I did a complete drawer refresh after receiving my first pair. A little more expensive than others, but the quality seems to be terrific a few months in.

  • These compression shorts are by far the best I have ever owned and I have had a lot of them over the years from different brands. They’re super supportive and they stay perfectly in place and do not ride up at all. Awesome product and I will be buying more for sure! Don’t delay - buy these now!

  • I've been looking for some underwear that fits comfortably, is affordable and that don't ride up your leg. All Citizens checks all the boxes. I bought a pair of the Elite II Boxer briefs and I couldn't be happier. I like that I can get two pair for the same price as one of the "other" brands. Highly recommend these.

  • Best underwear ever! Money well spent. You get comfort at its best. I am purchasing many more soon.

  • Very few brands sell underwear with a horizontal fly, and the comfort and roominess in the front accommodates men on the more endowed side. The All Citizens brief's waistband and leg openings are very comfortable and do not bind, and neither the waistband nor the leg openings get loose during a full day’s wearing; they hold up perfectly. The horizontal fly was clearly designed for comfort and accessibility, and I do not have an issue with slippage or accidentally falling out. The roomy design in the front keeps everything from being smashed or strangled, but hold everything in its comfortable place. I have a 29 inch inseam, so boxer briefs with inseams longer than 3 inches are too long for me, so I can’t wait to try All Citizen trunks next with the 3 inch inseam.

  • The Elite II Trunks are the most comfortable trunks I've worn. The grippy things at the leg bottoms prevent them from riding up. The Paradise Pouch is amazeballs and the access panel makes it easy to do your business. A little on the pricey side, but...