4.8
97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
All Citizens
4.8 • 332 Reviews
•

4.8
97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
3y ago
Ordered one Elite II Boxer Brief to try. Gave it a test by wearing during different conditions. Super soft, comfortable and feels like a second skin and never rode up. After both hand & machine washing (hung dry,) the brief was as comfortable so I ordered an additional six, taking advantage of the bundle price. Received this shipment a bit faster than the first and the credit from my ‘test’ order was applied almost immediately. If you want a superior product and outstanding customer service, choose All Citizens. Will be back to restock when needed and have a look at other products I may need.
3y ago
Best boxers I have even worn, highly recommend the Elite II boxer briefs. I had previously tried the Elite II trunks, but the item I recieved had minor stitching issues, but the company handled this really well and sent me a new item. So based on this I highly recommend company and products. Cheers
3y ago
Absolutely comfortable. Great design and super soft.
3y ago
Favorite pair of underwear by far! They are comfortable and super soft. The pouch offers great support to alleviate chaffing. They don't ride up! EVER! These are the only underwear I am getting from now on.
3y ago
THE BEST BOXERS MONEY CAN BUY! Listen Linda listen if you try just one pair I guarantee you’ll be back to buy more! I did exactly what Citizen's said and that’s to buy one pair to test them out.. I Did that and there I was buying 6 more so I’d have one for everyday of the week! Best boxers I’ve ever paid for and can assure you I’m not buying boxers anyway else! Also when it comes to that Netflix and Chill time with the Paradise pocket…YES, Thank me later!
3y ago
First class shipping arrived faster than expected. The all citizens boxer briefs are so comfortable you can easily forget you’re wearing them. There’s no ride up on the thigh even after washing. My wife’s loves how they look on.
3y ago
Bought one pair to test them out out and they are terrific! Great separation, comfortable and the legs stay down - no ride up. So happy with them I bought two more pairs, highly recommend!
3y ago
First pair! Good choice! Comfortable all around and once I got comfortable with the pocket area, everyone was smiling. I look forward to the next purchase for more reviews
Verified purchase
3y ago
Product is super soft, supportive and good looking. I like the design as well. Only improvement would be faster shipping.
3y ago
An absolutely amazing product. Life changing.
3y ago
Got the Performance Shirt, Short sleeve. Stretchy, well form fitting, and getting more.
3y ago
I left a more detailed review directly with All Citizens, so I'll keep this one concise - These underwear are game-changers. Premium feel, breathable fabric where you need it, and their horizontal fly has become the standard on which I base all underwear with that design, and all for an excellent price.
3y ago
These boxer briefs are amazing! The elasticity is incredible, the mesh breathability is needed and well executed, and the style is just icing on the cake. Overall, my new favorite boxers!
3y ago
Not happy at all with another brand of men’s pouch briefs which really didn’t hold the ‘total package’ together, I bought one pair of All Citizens Elite II Briefs to try. They are flawless and I can’t speak more highly of them so have just ordered another six pairs to make the entire week totally comfortable. I’ve worn them at work on an offshore facility and they have passed the grind test and survived the daily industrial laundry! It’s just not worth buying cheap and nasty jocks. Grab some of these for sure!
3y ago
Tried a pair after being a CK modal wearer for years - they fit well, are soft, breathable, and don't squeeze the thighs too much. Will definitely consider buying more pairs as my current rotation wears out.
3y ago
Great materials great fit great color. I like them all no color prefrence
3y ago
Their products are top notch, in particular their Re: Luxe Paradise Pocket boxer briefs. Their Elite II boxer briefs took many steps back in their design and were very uncomfortable. Also, Their customer service could use some improvement. Their website that i clicked on from the link in their promotional email for a "Drawer Refresh" order did not work (virtually a blank page). When I contacted them via email, it took almost a solid week to receive a reply (not the claimed 24 - 48 hours). Eh, regardless, their clothing is superb and worth an exercise in patience for this high level of clothing enjoyment.
3y ago
The best boxers I have ever worn. Would highly recommend!
3y ago
Great experience, first pair wasn’t perfect they gave me a refund 2nd pair is great! Getting ready to order more!
3y ago
Excellent brand with superb products and responsible business practices. Literally the best underwear I have ever tried and I will never buy anything else.