All Citizens reviews and discussion

4.8

97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Silky-soft fabric handfeel
  • Secure, supportive pouch design
  • Reliable no-ride leg grippers
  • Convenient horizontal h-fly
  • Occasional heat retention issues
  • Tight thigh bands discomfort
  • Inconsistent pouch ergonomics
  • Limited colors and stock

All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

331 reviews and posts

  • These are the best of the new group of boxer briefs on the market in the areas of fit, function, performance and comfort! Then you add in that they are value priced compared to the other brands in this market (Boutique level or small brand mens underwear) and they are absolutely on the top of the pile litterally and figuratively

  • I have been updating my menswear. I had been wearing SAXX- which I was satisfied with, but decided to give Citizens a try. Super comfortable! The Luxe is my favorite. They are holding up very well so far- I have been wearing for about 6 months now. Waist band holding up wash after wash.

    Drawer refresh deals
  • I have 2 pairs of their underwear; the fabrics are comfortable and soft. The support they give is good. Definitely would buy more and again. Wish there were more colors other than the usual colors. So far they both have held up well after numerous wearing's and washings.

  • super comfortable! i've ordered three different types now (endurance compression, tactical compression, and Re: Luxe trunk... and i love all three!

  • Best underwear. Softest. Legs stay put and don’t ride up. Very comfortable.

  • These are super soft and comfortable. A lot of great features the horizontal fly is nice. The pouch is like a hug . Who wouldn't like that. If they they were made with merino wool. That's just a personal preference. That's the only think i can think of that would make them better. Good job All Citizens!!

  • Great product! I was skeptical of the pouch but it very comfortable. Really like the no ride up on the legs as well.

  • These are made of a nice soft material but DO ride up. I bought 8 pairs but after a month or 2 regret my decision to do so. I suffer from cutaneous t-cell lymphoma so what anything does to my skin comfort is critical. Not only DO these ride up the the ball pouch chafes my skin where the perimeter separates my balls from my legs.

  • These boxers are the best bang for your b̶u̶c̶k̶ balls. It is incredibly comfortable, with no ride-up and hardly any awkward readjusting. My only complaint would be that the waistband isn't as tight/snug around my waist as I had hoped; otherwise, it is fantastic and worth the money. I've already recommended these boxers to family/friends.

    Discount for review.
  • Bought the Pocket Boxer Brief with longer leg length. Excellent. Longer length is not excessively long. I am 6' and 195 lbs and they are less than mid thigh. Comfortable, and the legs DON'T ride up. Not hot and have a great feel in all the right places. No binding, chafing or twisting. Also did well after washing twice. No shrinkage and no stretching and still feel great.

  • Nothing but positive things to say about All Citizens customer service. These guys clearly have a lot of apparel competition; by treating their customers so well and cranking out high quality garments at a reasonable price, they have nowhere to go but up.

  • Exactly what I've been searching for! I initially tried the trunks style and honestly didn't find them as comfy as I hoped, and I almost tried another brand of underwear instead. But I decided to give the Boxer Briefs style a shot before looking elsewhere, and I'm so glad I did because these ones are absolutely perfect! I've done a ton of research on underwear brands and had some strict requirements for my next set of underwear, and the Re:Luxe Boxer Briefs are even better than I was initially hoping I'd find. They're soft, keep me nice and cool, the legs don't ride up, they're just long enough to help prevent chafing but not be too warm, and the pouch is just :chef's kiss: . And unlike all the other brands, these ones are actually affordable!

  • Of all the "pouch" boxer briefs on the market, and I have tried about half of a dozen, All Citizens boxer briefs have the only TRUE pouch for the boys. I noticed that I never had to re-situate for the entire day. The legs stayed in place, they were one of the most comfortable pairs I've ever worn, and my woman said my backside looked great in them! Ordering the drawer refresh now...

  • I purchased a pair of unders from All Citizens for my hubby, who has had health issues and needs more comfy unders. He loves these and wants me to order him more! He is very picky, so this is a huge endorsement!

  • I love the Elite II Boxer Brief. I have tried 2 other top of the line briefs, David Archy and Manmade and I was not near as happy as All Citizens. The grip is perfect and doesn’t allow them to ride up. The quality of material and craftsmanship is wonderful. The use of the pouch on the front is different but it works simple and nice. I’m very pleased and will be purchasing more.

  • Honestly, the most comfortable underwear I have ever had. Tried many, Pair of Thieves, Fruit of the Loom, Hanes, most of them and this company makes everything down there happy especially with the Paradise Pocket for your Go Nads !!! Comfortable is an understatement!!!!

  • Really god communications and service. Excellent product, really smooth ont he skin and washes well.

  • I just received my Undies (Luxe Paradise Pocket™ Trunk - Standard Fit) a few days ago. I received two colors. I have been wearing them for a couple of days now and they fit perfectly. I have had many undies claim that the waistband wouldn't roll or that the legs would not pull up. These are true to their word. First time for me for both not to happen. BTW I have a little bit of a tummy so this IS awesome!

  • Fantastic. No ride up what so ever which makes no wedgie. The paradise pouch is nice and the ventilation is top notch, no more swamp crotch.

  • Ordered one Elite II Boxer Brief to try. Gave it a test by wearing during different conditions. Super soft, comfortable and feels like a second skin and never rode up. After both hand & machine washing (hung dry,) the brief was as comfortable so I ordered an additional six, taking advantage of the bundle price. Received this shipment a bit faster than the first and the credit from my ‘test’ order was applied almost immediately. If you want a superior product and outstanding customer service, choose All Citizens. Will be back to restock when needed and have a look at other products I may need.