All Citizens reviews and discussion

4.8

97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Silky-soft fabric handfeel
  • Secure, supportive pouch design
  • Reliable no-ride leg grippers
  • Convenient horizontal h-fly
  • Occasional heat retention issues
  • Tight thigh bands discomfort
  • Inconsistent pouch ergonomics
  • Limited colors and stock

All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

331 reviews and posts

  • The best underwear I've found on the market. The h fly is fantastic. I got the compression shorts that I use during very physical work in a delivery industry. The only underwear I've found that don't ride up and hold their shape over time. Will only buy from here going forward. Also a fraction of the cost of brands with much worse products. My wife also likes how they look so that's always handy. The only thing I wish is that they make long John's or base layers for the colder months.

  • The product itself is amazing. The best made, most comfortable boxers I've purchased. And they are the lowest priced I've found. The only real problem is that the regular boxer type underwear have been out of stock for months. I guess that's probably a symptom of them being so good, but still frustrating. I have both the regular boxers and the boxer briefs, and they're both great, but I prefer the regular boxers.

  • Very comfortable. Very durable. Holds the boys perfect. Only negative is during workouts they ride up!

  • Extremely soft and comfortable, stay where they are supposed to throughout the day… no problems with quality of stitching or anything at this point

  • The elite 2 trunks in xs are great for a 29 waist. I love the look and feel. Buttery soft, easy access unless you low ride your pants. And super easy helpful customer service.

  • Great underwear soft and comfortable

  • I've been looking for a pair of underwear that provides support and separation and have tried other premium brands, but I have to say that the All Citizens paradise pocket brief is the most comforatble pair of briefs that I now own. In fact, I have several pair and will definately order more.

  • I have multiple pairs of them and plan to buy more. Fit was good and the boys like the paradise pocket. The material is good and soft. My only sticking point is I wish the bundle packs were more affordable.

  • I’ve purchased dozens of different kinds of underwear. The elite II are hands down my absolute favorite! The stay put legs, the ball separation, and the material are all exquisite quality for the price point, especially given the next best in line is another ten dollars per pair. Highly recommend!

  • I have now replaced all my SAXX boxers with All Citizens. They are extremely comfortable at a great price. The material is buttery smooth. The best part about them is the ball pouch... you guys nailed it with this feature. The support they give is amazing.

    No relationship.
  • One of the best purchases I’ve ever made. I know that sounds silly, but they’re my favorite pair of boxers I’ve ever had. Incredibly comfortable, they fit so well. I’ve tried a bunch of other brands and nothing made me quite as happy as these did. I’ve purchased from them many, many times already.

  • I ordered 1 pair of the standard boxer briefs, just to see if I liked the ball pouch idea. I was great! So comfortable! I decided to order another pair, this time the Elite. These are GREAT! These are going to be my new "go to" underwear. I love the fact that they have the non-slip material on the legs. It keeps the legs from riding up. I think they have invited the PERFECT pair of underwear!

  • All Citizens has some great underwear. The ball pocket is the best part of this underwear, but the comfort of the material is high quality as well. The only downfall is that the back rides down a bit when bending over due the underwear not moving around because of the grip on the thighs. Other than this, the comfort and quality is outstanding. The customer service has been great as well, only wish they had an actual phone number because I like talking to people instead of emailing. Consider me old school.

  • Their underwear is so soft and comfortable

  • I have both e the original and Elite 2 versions of the paradise pouch boxer briefs, as well as some perfomance tee shirts. I can say that they are truly some of the most comfortable underwear I have owned! My first pair was a bit tight in the thighs, so they sent the athletic fit quickly and at no charge. They are great. It takes a bit to get used to how the boys settle into the pocket, but now it is automatic and the support and comfort s outstanding. The t-shirts are a nice medium weight that hold their shape well. I'll be purchasing from them again!

  • The Boxers are the best I have ever worn. I was at first a septic with how the pounce would work but it has truly been a game changer. I also love how the bottoms do not ride up due to the material at the bottom of the boxers.

  • It may not be the sexiest underwear, but it really is the most comfortable and best fitting underwear I’ve found. No leg ride up or upward motion at all. They’ve really become my go-to.

  • The boxer brief has become my go-to for workouts and exercising. They get put through quite a work-out themselves, no pun intended. If you're not satisfied with your current product, try this one. Remember, if you can't be an athlete, be an athletic supporter.

    Received a free product from All Citizens
  • Best undies ive ever owned!

  • Very comfortable and great quality