All Citizens reviews and discussion

4.8

97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Silky-soft fabric handfeel
  • Secure, supportive pouch design
  • Reliable no-ride leg grippers
  • Convenient horizontal h-fly
  • Occasional heat retention issues
  • Tight thigh bands discomfort
  • Inconsistent pouch ergonomics
  • Limited colors and stock

All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

331 reviews and posts

  • The paradise pocket is legit! I usually wear underwear designed for playing sports as they usually help keep everything in place but the "pouch" is nothing more than just extra fabric. All Citizens paradise pocket is really comfortable, high quality, and just feels awesome. Wife really loves them too!

    Feedback

    I wish there were more pictures of of each product.

  • Love the product. They just seem to be out of styles that are in demand.

    Feedback

    Better inventory.

  • I love the fit they are very comfortable and supportive.

    Feedback

    Nothing but maybe more fun designs.

  • I love the product

    Feedback

    Nothing everything is fine

  • These are very good undies, never chafing, never pulling up, not binding. I think they are a superior product!

    Feedback

    They could have slightly more room for large dicks if you get erect otherwise perfect

  • Excellent products. I only buy these boxer briefs now. They are extremely comfortable and seem durable. Quality at this price point is unmatched. Buy the "drawer refresh" and don't look back!

    Feedback

    Nothing!

  • The best underwear available! I have friends who I've brought to the brand and we all agree.

    Feedback

    Keep exploring color options and designs. Happy with what exists but always looking to add to the collection.

  • I ordered a pair of the Luxe Paradise Pocket™ Boxer Brief - Athletic Fit and they are the most comfortable pouch underwear I have tried. The athletic fit is great for those of us who like to squat heavy!

    Feedback

    The material is sturdy and has areas that breathe, but I'd like to see an option for a lighter weight material that breathes better for hot environments.

  • I mean, I tried socks and underwear from the the top 4 brands that are either have good buzz. All citizens All birds Everlane Tommy John Literally the quality on all citizens was so much better than the rest like noticeable instantly. I only placed a test order but these will become the only socks/underwear I own

    Feedback

    They have an option to buy one and then if it’s within the return period get 9 more as a bundle and you get a discount which I totally intended on doing BUT they don’t give an email reminder that that window is closing so I missed the opportunity and ended up not buying anything else’s. I will in the future BUT that reminder would of made us both happier

  • Website is easy to navigate. Descriptions are complete. Wide selection. Ordered 1 pair as suggested by them and am very happy with my purchase. I will be ordering again.

  • Originally bought them as I had thick thighs and to prevent boxer brief riding up, which was MISERY with other boxer brief brands. The elastic at the bottom was fantastic, and I now have 3-4? year old all citizens, from the pre-pouch era, that work as well as they did when I first got them Since then they have incorporated the pouch, and really worked on their styling and comfort. Far better than alternative brands, at least for boxer briefs.

  • I have worn many different brands before including others with a "pouch". The All citizens boxer briefs are definitely one of the most comfortable pair that I have tried. i would recommend them to others.

  • I purchased the paradise pocket trunks and have been wearing them and a few other brands of pouched boxers for several months. The All Citizens are, by far, the most comfortable and supportive trunk style boxers I’ve ever owned. The material is thicker, but breaths better than thinner boxer briefs. These are my go-to underwear. They are also quite affordable for the quality!

    Feedback

    I don’t see any need for improvement.

  • Most secure pair of boxer briefs I have. Way more comfortable than compression briefs, but keeps everything in place. Horizontal fly is a great feature also.

  • It was time to revamp my underwear drawer. I ordered from probably ten different companies. The winner? All Citizens! Great fit, silky fabric, love the Paradise Pocket. The horizontal fly is a great innovation. The price is the best of any realistic underwear (some really funky, cheap designs out there!) Looking forward to the undershirts when they ship.

  • Customer service is very helpful and friendly via email. Just trying to get a comfortable fitting pair of their boxer briefs that will work for my size.

    Feedback

    Nothing negative, I just wish they offered a lighter weight fabric material like a bamboo blend or modal blend as another option as well as there current material for the humid summer climates here is all.

  • Crazy comfortable and super fast shipping.

    Feedback

    Out of stock patterns

  • Very nice i have about 15 pairs very comfy will buy more when needed

    Feedback

    Would like to see neon colors

  • Responsive customer service. Great pricing. Fit and quality of the shirts is fantastic. Material is soft on the skin but has a spandex-like feel to it which may or may not be a good thing.

    Feedback

    Frustrating that many sizes and colors of light weight shirts are all out of stock.