All Citizens reviews and discussion

4.8

97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Silky-soft fabric handfeel
  • Secure, supportive pouch design
  • Reliable no-ride leg grippers
  • Convenient horizontal h-fly
  • Occasional heat retention issues
  • Tight thigh bands discomfort
  • Inconsistent pouch ergonomics
  • Limited colors and stock

All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

331 reviews and posts

  • My new favorite underwear - I never splurged on premium boxers before but it's a game changer for sure. The shipping was very fast and the material feels very luxurious. I've had them for a few months now and they are holding up well. Love that they have a thicker thigh option for the width of the legs too! My wife loves how they look, too.

    Feedback

    The ball pouch sits a little high and feels kind of small for me and I do sometimes have to readjust that - I prefer the ones without the pouch as a result.

  • The Performance Dress Shirt is probably the best dress shirt that I own. It works for all weather and climate, and doesn't feel horrible when it is hot and humid. The tapered design is great for those who have a slim build but broad shoulders. From my experience, the price is nice compared to other performance brands.

    Feedback

    I would like to see more inventory for the Performance Dress Shirt so there's not such long wait times between restocks. I would also like to see more colors and designs, and perhaps even a blazer or more chino colors in the future so I can try those out.

  • The items arrived quickly but I had to return to get the athletic cut cause I have bigger thighs which I expected to happen. The underwear were soft and comfortable even tho they were too tight so I ordered more in the right size.

    Feedback

    Less deductions for refunds and exchanges; allow first pair return policy to be used with feel good return policy for first time users

  • I loved the performance boxers I ordered and am ordering more. The website was informative on the sizing and material and was transparent on the return policy if they didn’t work out.

    Feedback

    I don’t really have any complaints. Maybe a bit expensive.

  • I kinda thought boxers were boxers, and briefs were briefs. That's not the case. These things are next-level.

    Feedback

    The price is pretty high, but I'm just a 9-5 sub-human pleb. A discounted pack of 7 would be pretty legit. Don't most people do laundry weekly? Am I a freak!?

  • Just replaced my underwear of over 10 years with a dozen pairs of these. They are simply awesome. The do NOT ride up, and they have a great pouch to keep everything cradled and separate. I've had to return one pair due to defect and had to ask a couple of questions and their customer service has been responsive and knowledgeable. You simply can't beat the quality, especially for this price. 100% recommended.

    Feedback

    Had one defective item out of 14 purchased. Was given no hassle on a replacement.

  • I bought a couple of of their boxer briefs with the paradise pocket and a pair of compression shorts because I have a hard time finding underwear that provides lasting support and that keeps everything from sticking to one leg. Right away I thought the fabric was far more comfortable than many of my other “nice” pairs of underwear and I can say after months of washing they still hold up and the elastic has stayed strong. What really sells me on the brand though is that I wore them going on a 6 hour long flight that was first canceled and then delayed twice. Almost 36 hours of constant wear, running around, and overall feeling super gross. They kept their support and didn’t ride up my legs or up my butt. This, plus the reasonable price tag, bundling options, and color and size range makes this brand one of my favorites.

    Feedback

    I’d like the compression shorts to have a larger phone pocket.

  • Website was accurate and easy to use. Sizing was spot on, and the quality of the product is on the bullseye.

    Feedback

    I wish it was easier to try things out after the first purchase.

  • Good quality, very comfortable. Was exactly what I was looking for. Quick delivery.

  • I ordered 3 pair of paradise boxers and was very happy after trying them on. Very comfortable with a nice hammock on the inside for the boys to relax, lol. Much better than the crap I got from Tommy John and at half the price!!

    Feedback

    Nothing, even delivery was great cause 2 days later I had my order

  • The stretch material is super soft and comfortable, and the length of the boxer briefs is perfect..not to long, not to short. The "paradise pocket" keeps the boys in place, just like they claim. (And) finally, there's a good selection of patterns and prints to choose from. I love this product! Gary

    Feedback

    Nothing. I'm extremely satisfied with Citizens boxer briefs.

  • All Citizens customer service is 2nd to none! Everyone that I have interacted with is super cool and very helpful. It's underwear, and you can tell that they love what they do.

    Feedback

    I know that briefs are not as popular, but would like to see all white added to the lineup. I hear that they are coming soon!

  • I was very pleasantly surprised to receive a well-priced, quality product from a Facebook ad! My Facebook ad experiences have been horrid, so I'm not sure what possessed me to buy this product, but I'm glad I did. I have a drawer full of "Crazy Boxer" brand underwear that I like, but I was intrigued by the recent development of ball hammock designs available. After trying this product, I can't imagine buying underwear again without the hammock design. It's very comfortable.

    Feedback

    It takes some getting used to when putting the underwear on to stuff your goods into the pouch opening. There must be a more natural way of making this happen. Also I'm not happy with the website. The little orange dot instead of a normal curser is irritating, and there needs to be more detailed descriptions of hammock features and "how-tos."

  • I've had an opportunity to try three products so far: the runweight v neck shirt, the performance dress shirt, and the re:luxe paradise pocket boxer brief in an athletic fit. Overall, the product quality is great, but I've run into a couple of annoyances. The Performance Dress Shirt is perhaps my favorite white dress shirt I've ever owned. It doesn't wrinkle easily, BUT the creases from the initial shipment were a real pain, surviving the first wash and several attempts to iron them out. I love the thickness of the material; most dress shirts are too sheer/transparent for my taste. It also feels great, and the trim fit was cut perfectly for me. I recently took it along in a small carry-on and was pleased it didn't wrinkle much. The Paradise Pocket isn't explained very well on the boxer brief product page. I found the inner "pocket" opening to be placed a little too high for my anatomy, making my "goods" feel choked rather than cradled. That doesn't mean the design is a complete failure, though. The fact the pocket is sized to accommodate an entire package ultimately means the fly doesn't pinch the way traditional boxer brief flies do. It is also possible to use the pocket to separate the package from itself (rather than complete separation from the thighs), though I'm sure this varies from person to person. As for the runweight shirt, it is soft and stretchy. My initial reaction was that it was too soft to be athletic wear (it contours to bumpy skin or short hairs), but over time I've grown to love how it feels and holds up wash after wash (at least on permanent press cold cycles). Zero issues with the purchase process or with the shipment.

    Feedback

    One area I'd like to see All Citizens improve is their website. Many of the products have only a single photo accompanying them, making it difficult to make an informed purchase decision. I've also experienced a few glitches, e.g. I had difficulty selecting my size on some of the product pages.

  • Stunningly comfortable underwear. Fabric is super comfy and there’s no chaffing. As a bonus these are great for rowing and work better than anything else I’ve tried. And they’re priced very reasonably.

    Feedback

    My only complaint is the fabric could be more breathable in the areas where there’s fabric overlap

  • The all citizens briefs quickly replaced most of my other underwear and it now fills most of my drawer. They also work wonderfully for exercising. The undershirts are wonderful too, especially the V-neck- they work wonders under shirts I don't want to get dirty.

    Feedback

    Adding long sleeve shirts that aren't collared and adding more styles for the boxers.

  • Great service and excellent product. Have tried many brands, but All Citizens are my favorite boxer briefs!

    Feedback

    Would like to see some longer length boxer briefs.

  • Love the new looks. Swapping out all boxers. Great Comfort

    Feedback

    More colorways

  • I have purchased from them three times so far. I love the hammock underwear and am slowly replacing all of my boxers with them.

  • Got the pouch boxers. Amazing fit, feels great on the boys. Really like the vertical fly.