All Citizens reviews and discussion

High quality material. Fit well. Decent price. Night recommend.

My boyfriend was reluctant as he normally ONLY wears boxers and not boxer briefs. He LOVED these!! The fabric is so silky soft and the price is very reasonable compared to other brands. Will be ordering more!

These are amazing. I love the quality of them and the comfort. I also really like the fact that they give guidance up front on how to wash for longevity. I’ve been doing about everything in them since purchasing. Love the athletic fit since I’ve got some free trunk thighs

I contacted All Citizens through website chat and discussed the high cost of shipping ($15) to HI for a planned initial purchase of one pair of underwear and one t-shirt. All Citizens responded saying if I paid for shipping on the first order, and placed a second order of $45 or more, that they would refund shipping on both orders ($30). Based on this agreement, I placed my first order. Items fit, so I placed my second order for another 3 pairs of underwear and 1 t-shirt. After placing my second order, I again engaged All Citizens through website chat to request my $30 shipping refund. All Citizens then responded stating that their representative gave me the wrong information, and that they would not refund shipping, but instead offered me a discount on a third order should I place one. I responded via chat and email with my unhappiness, but received no response. So here I sit with 4 pairs of underwear and 2 t-shirts that probably weigh 1 lb in total, and I was charged $30 for shipping. Not too cool in my books, and I won't be duped into placing a 3rd order. **Update** Begrudgingly, I received my underwear and t-shirt order from All Citizens. I was still pouting over the whole ordeal, so it took me a few days to get around to trying on the new threads. When I did try them on, I had to admit they were really comfortable. Two weeks later, I received a message from All Citizens apologizing for the mistake and they refunded me $30 for shipping. I feel All Citizens made things 100% right, and I’m happy with the outcome. Based on this, I would recommend the company and their products. I am leaving my original review intact, as it was part of the entire experience with a positive ending.

Most comfortable underwear I have ever worn, almost like not wearing any.

On my boxer brief quest, I ordered some samples from All Citizens (classic standard for $16/pair), and—since I listen to podcasts and couldn't escape the marketing—Mack Weldon. I found All Citizens to be classier, more comfortable, and more secure (I felt more supported, and the legs did not ride up—the Mack Weldons typically did). Plus, the horizontal fly really does feel like a more sensible design. I'm very thin (26" waist, 5'8," 115 lbs), so All Citizens carrying XS sizing is a boon. Unfortunately, the elastic waistband on my first pair completely stretched out, and fairly quickly, despite washing in cold water and using low-temperature drying. I've been a little more precious with my second pair and either hand-washing or machine-washing and leaving to air-dry, which has been much better, but I recognize I may be overcorrecting. Maybe it was a fluke (other reviews seem to have had much better luck with waistband longevity), or maybe it's a flaw with the material. Either way, these were still my favorites and I intend to order more.

I’ve tried a few other brands of boxer briefs with pockets for the boys, I wore one of those brands for almost a decade. But after spending that kind of money, I saw these for half the price and figured I would try them! I’m sure glad I did! The pocket spare things very well and adds so much support. The legs don’t ride up, and they just fit well over all?

I've thought about what it would be like to have a boxer brief that had the support of a brief. I hate that your boys don't stay in place and always having to adjust. I then came across All Citizens and saw an ad for the Paradise Pocket Boxer Brief. I decided to buy a pair and see. Wow! The fabric is soft, the Paradise Pocket cradles the boys and keeps them in place and provides excellent support. I tried another company's similar boxer brief with a similar pocket for the boys, but they didn't even compare to the Paradise Pocket from All Citizens! I will keep buying and the price is right!

Elite 2 design is off the charts, so comfortable and convenient to wear. They’re the most comfortable underwear I’ve ever bought. Really soft fabric, breathable, legs don't ride up. Price is exceptional for the quality.

The Tactical II Compression shorts are great!. They fit very well and provide good all-around compression. The legs don't ride up due to strong elastic bands, which may be a smidge too strong. But they're great compression shorts, regardless.

Incredible! The most unique, the most comfortable boxer briefs known to man. I have tried them all and all citizens are simply miles above the rest! No competition Edit: 2/20/2023 I decided to give their undershirt a try too; UNBELIEVABLE! This company can do no wrong. I want to try their dress shirt next. Worth a go at $68 vs a similarly priced one by Rhône or Mizzen + Main!

I was very skeptical about trying these underwear but reading about the material and how the pouch would help support my junk, I had to give it a try. Boy was I surprised. The fit was perfect, the size in the front seemed a little small as I wear my underwear high. It seemed to fit right and my pubic area. This was my only drawback. What I really loved was the leg part. The inside part of the leg area had this type of material which keeps it in place and it does not ride up on me. This was the best part. Having worn underwear all my life and having them ride up and bunch up near the crotch, then having to pull the leg down gets really annoying. I'm buying these underwear for my entire wardrobe and throwing away the current set I have now. Thank you All Citizens you came through in the underwear fashion for men.

Easily the best and most comfortable underwear I have purchased. The paradise pocket 2.0 is flawless and the goods sit very comfortably. This is now my go to pair for every day and even up to a comfortable 18 mile run. I'll be buying more for my marathon later this year!

These Boxer Briefs Elite are truly elite indeed. I have only worn them once since purchasing. I wore them all day. Sitting, standing, moving around. Everything was held in place and no adjustments whatsoever. The new 2.0 pocket is truly a bliss.

Out of all the pouch boxers I have worn these are by far the best. They don't ride up and are extremely comfortable.

These boxer briefs are the best combo of quality and affordability compared to some of the other options out there.

I bought the $99 drawer refresh about 2 years ago now and every single pair of boxer briefs from that purchase is still going strong. That was my first time buying higher-quality underwear; last year, I added another pair and I have yet to be disappointed!

I received a pair of paradise pocket boxer briefs and was amazed by the feel of the fabric. These are my go-to underwear - they're comfortable, soft, durable, and prevents unwanted stickage. After multiple washes, they have kept up with little to no sign of wear.

Bought my first set 5 years ago in 2017, and still wear them today. Elastics at waist and legs are still holding firm, with zero riding up the leg. The fact that they don't ride up the leg is easily the most impressive part of their design when it comes to longterm, daily comfort.

Took the plunge into spending a bit more on underwear. My first purchase was not a great fit for me, but customer service was amazing and helped me find something that fit better (longer inseam). Quality and fit are top notch.