Thingtesting Logo

Tillamook

4.8 • 22 Reviews

•

tillamook.comArrow up right
Tillamook

Tillamook reviews and discussion

4.8

94% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Tangy, robust cheddar flavor
  • Creamy, indulgent ice cream texture
  • Melty, consistent shredded cheese
  • Distinctive, crowd-pleasing ice cream flavors
  • Inconsistent ice cream mix-ins
  • Ordinary-tasting butter option
  • Microwaved mac texture suffers
  • Occasionally cheap-tasting ice cream

Tillamook earns strong reviews and decisively proves it is good: its sharp and extra sharp cheddars deliver full, tangy flavor and melt beautifully, and the ice cream is praised for rich, creamy textures and standout flavors like Marionberry Pie and Sea Salt Honeycomb Toffee. Reviews also flag inconsistencies—some ice cream flavors feel cheap with sparse mix-ins, butter underwhelms versus store alternatives, and microwave-prepped mac and cheese lacks optimal texture compared to oven baking.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

22 reviews and posts

  • 3y ago

    I've tried Tillamook shredded cheese like for salad toppings. It does have a better, more rich taste but of course it was higher in price than the store brand or other familiar brands. I'd buy it again if it was on sale.