4
84% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Nick's
4.0 • 23 Reviews
•
Nick's reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Creamy, satisfying ice cream texture
- Flavorful, robust signature flavors
- Chewy, pleasant protein bar texture
- Lower-sugar, lower-calorie formulations
- Occasional watery, icy texture
- Sweetener aftertaste in some flavors
- Overly sweet flavor profile
- Sugar alcohol digestive discomfort
Nick's earns largely positive reviews for creamy, flavorful “light” ice cream and satisfying 15 g protein bars, indicating the brand is good at delivering lower-calorie treats that don’t taste diet. Reviews praise rich textures, strong flavors, and standout varieties like Triple Choclad, Birthday Cake, Coffee Karamell, and Cherry Choka Flaka, while calling out issues such as occasional watery or icy pints, odd sweetener aftertaste, excessive sweetness for some, sugar-alcohol stomach discomfort, and inconsistent flavor enjoyment.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
23 reviews and posts
3y ago
texture was 10/10 for a low cal/low fat icecream, however there was a weird aftertaste probably due to it being sugar free. the sugar alcohols did 100% mess up my stomach (bloating, gas) and it is pretty pricey as well. may not be repurchasing but pretty enjoyable to eat if i disregard how i feel after
3y ago
The ice cream has a fantastic texture, not watery. The flavours with chunks are substantial and the ones with swirls have a good amount mixed in; could have more. Haven't experienced too many pockets of air in the pints. My favourite so far, the Cherry Choka Flaka, has a good, natural cherry flavour and the chocolate bits are not too hard. But overall, I have enjoyed every flavour and look forward to trying more.
Feedback
It is a bit pricey. But overall, the product is better than the competition.
4y ago
better than halo top fs
Feedback
expensive !