Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams

Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion

4.7

95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend

Reviews mention

  • Velvety, ultra-creamy texture
  • Inventive, distinctive flavors
  • Plentiful, well-distributed mix-ins
  • Impressive dairy-free options
  • Inconsistent flavor execution
  • Occasionally icy, grainy texture
  • Some flavors overly sweet
  • Variable creaminess across pints

Jeni's Ice Creams earns rapturous reviews for rich, ultra‑creamy texture and inventive, true‑to‑label flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, confirming the brand is excellent. Reviews also flag downsides: pints are expensive, quality varies by flavor, and some report iciness or overly sweet/salty notes and occasional freezer burn from stores.

AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews

1,842 reviews and posts

  • still dreaming about the ted lasso collab, it was INCREDIBLE!

  • Love all the flavors of Jeni's Ice Creams. Soooo good!

  • The brumbleberry crisp and gooey butter cake flavors are my all time favorite ice cream flavors!

  • now this is a tasty ice cream! I love ice cream and this tastes rich and butterly. Nice lasting palate for another bite.

  • He is is great. As someone who can’t eat dairy, I love that they have dairy free options. My only complaint is that I wish they had more dairy free options. I find that they are the same ones and could use some refreshing / variety more often.

  • Taste so so so good.

    Influencer for Jeni's Ice Creams
  • Jeni’s makes me proud to be from C-bus, OH! It’s so smooth, creamy, and perfectly balanced in flavor. They have the best variety with unique flavors, while still honoring the classics. Also, the staff is always cheerful and welcoming.

    Feedback

    Absolutely worth visiting anytime you have the chance. There is something there for everyone. Even the dairy free options are creamy and delicious. I miss the sundaes with the hand whipped cream!

  • Had some of this delicious ice cream while visiting son and daughter in law in Virginia. I’m usually a mint chocolate chip lover but had the brambleberry crisp and brown butter almond brittle. Both were delicious! I got in a fresh waffle cone which just added to the deliciousness of the ice cream. Loved it!

    Feedback

    Give this ice cream a try! It is so worth it.

  • Great ice cream although they're more like high quality novelties. They are delicious. Flavors are great and innovative.

    Feedback

    Great flavors. Prices are way high. Probably good as it's not healthy food. But it's delicious so I don't have much else to say.

  • Best ice cream I’ve ever had

  • One of my all time favorite ice creams ever! Super creamy and very flavorful with unique flavors you don't typically find in other brands. My go to is Birthday Cake but Gooey Butter Cake is also a solid choice! Also saw that they're getting into the sorbet game so looking forward to trying those as well! Also didn't know that it's a female founded company - makes it even better :)

  • One of my favorite ice creams. I was spoiled by living near a shop so got to try all the flavors. Prices seem to fluctuate based on the store.

    Feedback

    I hope they can work with grocery stores to pickup more flavors. My grocery store only has 5-6.

  • Jeni’s is always there to pick me up when I’m down. Unbelievable, realistic tasting flavors that don’t taste artificial. Definitely on the pricier side, but ultimately worth it.

    Feedback

    Some flavors definitely pack more of a punch than others, but everyone has their fav! Def recommend purchasing at Whole Foods as they’ll sometimes have a few dollars off.

  • Had Jeni’s whilst in Chicago last summer & it was sooo yummy! I had their strawberry flavour & it was TDF.

  • Love Jeni's Ice Cream! Super innovative flavors, easy ordering process online, and overall delicious.

  • Brambleberry crisp was divine. Looking forward to trying other flavors

  • My favorite kind of ice cream - particularly love the Brambleberry Crisp & Blackout Chocolate Cake. Incredibly "gooey" texture that most other ice creams don't have!

    Feedback

    Would love any more experimentation with flavors!

  • I would say I never had a bad flavor of Jeni's, but sometimes there is a miss. (I'm looking at you Biscuits for the Boss. That tasted way too sweet and needed something salty to bring it balance) Their pints are always worth the splurge.

    Feedback

    Always get a sample of the flavor before committing to a pint.

  • The flavors are too bold. We also do love basic flavors too.

  • I’ve had this ice cream a few times and it’s always pretty good. I’ve tried a few flavors and all of them were tasty.

    Feedback

    Their line is always long. Maybe open up or hire more associates to help out