4.7
95% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
Jeni's Ice Creams
4.7 • 1,841 Reviews
•
Jeni's Ice Creams reviews and discussion
Reviews mention
- Velvety, creamy texture
- Inventive, distinctive flavors
- High-quality, clean ingredients
- Strong dairy-free options
- Overly sweet for some palates
- Inconsistent flavor intensity
- Icy texture after refreezing
- Rich, heavy mouthfeel
Jeni's Ice Creams wins praise in reviews for its ultra-creamy texture, inventive flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Gooey Butter Cake, and Brown Butter Almond Brittle, and strong dairy-free/gluten-free options—so yes, the brand is good. Reviews also flag drawbacks: many find it very sweet and rich, inconsistently punchy by flavor, prone to freezer burn or iciness in pints, and expensive compared to alternatives.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
1,841 reviews and posts
It is on the expensive side for ice cream but totally worth it. Delicious flavor combinations, ice cream is rich and creamy. Fast shipping and comes packed to stay cold.
One of my favorite ice cream brands! Definitely worth the splurge :)
4y ago
All time favorite ice cream brand. So many good flavors especially the peanut butter with chocolate flecks.
Feedback
Price, but it’s worth it
Expensive but so good.
Absolutely love Jeni’s, had no idea it existed until Tyler, the Creator collaborated with them. I haven’t bought their pints as I’ve been fortunate to visit their physical locations. They produce quality ice cream so my hope is that their prepackaged pints do the trick.
Feedback
I’d love a location in the Bay Area but progressive expansion is the goal, wouldn’t want quality to suffer.
So delicious!!! The Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks is the best thing I've ever tasted!
Feedback
I wish it was a bit healthier with natural ingredients
My favorite ice cream...ever! I absolutely love this brand and the range of flavors. Their sets make awesome gifts as well.
Feedback
I would love to see Jeni's offer more dairy free flavors.
Great fun and creative flavors
i love jenis ice cream!! The flavors are so unique and its so creamy.
Love the innovative and creative flavors. Definitely my favorite grocery store ice cream. 10/10
4y ago
LOVE Jeni’s so much. The flavors are phenomenal and the ice cream is so creamy!
I always had wanted to try Jeni's ice creams but never did until recently - and I was not disappointed by what I tasted, it was DELICIOUS! I tried the Gooey butter cake flavor which was probably one of the best ice cream flavors that I have ever tried. I also got to experience one of the Jeni's ice cream stores in downtown Charleston, SC and it was an awesome experience. I can't wait until they put the location in near my house, I will be there probably a little too often!!
Feedback
I think that it is a bit expensive in the grocery store for a pint but I know that you are paying for what you get with the high quality ingredients and unique flavor combinations.
Best ice cream. Also flavors are amazing.
These are actually superior ice creams. It’s a high price point but absolutely worth it for a splurge as the flavor is unrivaled.
Delicious fun flavors but definitely on the more expensive side of novelty ice cream
Great, fun flavors! Super high quality ice cream. The salted caramel is *chefs kiss*
Excellent ice creams and sorbet!
Feedback
Pricing is steep.
4y ago
Jeni's is indeed the bomb and worth every penny. Would definitely recommend for ice cream lovers who appreciate quality ingredients and interesting flavor combinations!
Truly the best ice cream out there. The flavors and quality are top notch.
Feedback
Love the non-dairy options and would like to see more!
I love their vegan and gluten free options!