4.8
97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
All Citizens
4.8 • 331 Reviews
•

4.8
97% of reviewers would recommend to a friend
All Citizens earns strong reviews for exceptionally comfortable men’s basics—especially Re:Luxe Paradise Pocket, Elite II, and Apex III boxer briefs that prevent ride-up, reduce chafing, and keep “the boys” supported—yet mixed feedback questions pouch execution for some body types and notes limited colors and inventory gaps. Reviews also praise soft, durable fabrics, leg grippers, and the horizontal H-fly, while recurring complaints cite tight thigh bands, heat retention in high temps, occasional waistband wear, and frustrating customer service and return policies.
AI summary based on Thingtesting reviews
4y ago
Awesome products. I've tried many different pouch underwear from several brands. But they nailed the concept of separating your goods from your thighs with boxers/boxer briefs. Their response time to my concerns was swift and are great to work with.
Feedback
They have some great designs but much of it is out of stock, and unavailable rather quickly. I'd purchase more if they had options available. They also ship with UPS, which along with FedEx, isn't exactly the most reliable from personal experience. Your mileage may vary.
4y ago
I love these underwear ! Everything stays where it should and it helps keep it cool. I can't wait to buy me more of them. Well worth the money!
Feedback
Nothing I like just like they are
4y ago
Really high quality under garments at affordable prices!
Feedback
Free shipping On first pair!
4y ago
The paradise pouch boxer briefs are the best pouch underwear I have tried. The others don’t seem to actually hold things into place as good as these do. I have had them for 1.5 years and they are holding up great! I like that even their “fun” designs are not super loud and obnoxious, but rather subtle. Also, some people don’t like the elastic in the legs but I personally love it. Keeps them from riding up throughout the day. They knocked it out of the park with these, including the cost - it’s middle of the road cost wise but high end feel and longevity.
Feedback
I would like to see more stripe variety of patterns but other than that the product it’s self is perfect.
4y ago
The boxers overall are fine, the fit and fabric are good, the only thing I didn't like was the elastic in the bottom of the thigh. Even with the athletic fit it was still to tight. Customer support gets a 10/10 for helping me with my issue
Feedback
A boxer brief without elastic bands in the thigh
4y ago
Seriously, this is the most comfortable underwear I have ever worn. Supporting in the right spots, giving in the right spots, no ride up. So good, that I could probably wear for multiple days and not notice.
4y ago
The Paradise Pocket Boxer Briefs are the best pair of underwear I have ever tried! They’re soft, breathable, they don’t ride up excessively, the pouch feels nice, and the underwear comes in cool colors and patterns. Shipping was reasonably-priced and fast.
Feedback
1. They’re air-dry only 2. They’re Out of Stock for colors I want 3. They’re $18/pair or $99 for 6 pairs.
4y ago
The pouch is really great. There are a lot of different underwear brands, but this is definitely in the top tier.
Feedback
The longer leg boxer briefs rode up a bit, but may have been a sizing issue.
4y ago
The fabric was soft and the Pouch was supportive.
Feedback
Nothing
4y ago
I own three pairs of paradise pocket athletic briefs and they are absolutely phenomenal. Sign up for the mailing list, get the discount and see for yourself!
Feedback
There is no reason to change their product!
4y ago
I bought all citizen underwear for my husband and he absolutely loves them! The website is easy to use and shipping was fast. Compared to other similar products from other brands he has tried, he prefers all citizens underwear for both quality and reasonable pricing.
4y ago
All citizens does modern, innovative menswear with ultralight branding. It’s refreshing to see.
Feedback
The website can be difficult to use on some mobile browsers.
4y ago
My husband enjoys wearing these. The fabric is so soft, shorts are durable. He finds them very comfortable, says "Order more". I like like the color and pattern choices, so I will!
4y ago
Have multiple pairs of the underwear. Very comfortable, good quality at a fair price. Highly recommend over the other companies that charge way more to cover their marketing.
4y ago
Best underwear out there. Extremely high quality, silky soft and breathable. They work great for athletics too as the attention to detail with the mesh air flow panels. I love the pouch that offers extra support, and honestly can't wear underwear without it anymore. I ordered one model I didn't quite love on my body, and their customer service is top notch.
Feedback
None. Perfecttttt
4y ago
Well made, super comfy and has lasted me a long time for the price. They don’t ride up.
Feedback
The flap on the pouch can sometimes be a problem
4y ago
Purchased boxers for my husband and he absolutely loves them! They are long lasting and comfortable. Definitely recommend this brand!
4y ago
I absolutely love my Paradise Pocket boxers from here! The material is comfortable and lightweight, the horizontal fly is a beautiful thing, and the price is cheaper than most pocket underwear. Overall, I will never buy another brand of boxers!
Feedback
Nothing at all!
4y ago
Simply the best underwear I've worn. Long lasting, well made and incredibly comfortable
4y ago
I purchased a number of their paradise pocket boxers and I think they are an excellent product for a good price